|Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format
|WorldWar2.ro Forum > Reviews & Bookstore > modern russian historians|
|Posted by: guina August 27, 2010 10:12 pm|
| I just finished reading the new book of Mark Solonin on 22 of June 1941.Unfortunately ,is available,for the time beeing just in russian bu i'm sure an english translation will follow.The purpose of this posting is to draw attention of fellow members on an important russian historian of the new generation.More about him,here
|Posted by: MMM August 29, 2010 12:56 pm|
|So what's new in this book, compared to other books on the same subject? Could you tell us in a couple of words what new theories does Mr. Solonin have? Please...|
|Posted by: guina August 29, 2010 05:10 pm|
| OK,I promise,give me a couple of days.
BTW did you read this
|Posted by: MMM August 29, 2010 06:03 pm|
|No, I will read it tonight / tomorrow! Thanks!|
|Posted by: Dénes August 30, 2010 05:55 am|
I would be most interested in reading this book on air forces, in English.
The author's page has a note on the top:
"Сhapters, available for download, you will find on the bottom of that page."
However, I cannot find any downloadable links. Do I understand the sentence correctly?
|Posted by: muggs August 30, 2010 06:29 am|
|I think it's just an error in the translation, some chapters ( or parts of them ) are indeed there but not for download, they are accesible via normal html links.|
|Posted by: MMM August 30, 2010 09:34 am|
That's at the bottom of the page - not downloadable, but "select-copy-paste" works if necessary! Better than nothing, I guess...
|Posted by: guina August 30, 2010 12:43 pm|
For now,the book which apeared in 2007,is translated only in polish,lithuanian and estonian.I understood from mister V.Dimarski,that the english translation is completed and the book will apear in UK next year.A german version is suposed to be aveilable from october(my source,on this ,is not reliable).One can find his works,for sale in his original site
http://www.solonin.org/ (russian version ) which,BTW,is much richer than the english version.
I'll keep my word,but i think you got an idea of what is all about.
|Posted by: MMM August 30, 2010 02:36 pm|
|Well, yes, I did! Didn't read ALL the excerpts, but it's nice to know there is a good historian with new approaches; historian, not spy-turned-historian, like Mr. Rezun/Suvorov!|
|Posted by: guina September 06, 2010 02:22 pm|
| Well,3 M,this is the main theory of mr. Solonin:
1.The myth promotet by soviet historians after the XX congres of the SCP and Hruschevs speech during the same event,puting all the defeats of RKKA on account of material inferiority,surprise,lack of competent oficers due to the purges of 37-39,units being withdrawn from the borders,is jut that-a myth.In reality,Red Army was fully prepared for the war,being far superior to the enemy.Only tanks and planes,they had more that ALL European countries all toghether.They were not surprised either,starting 12 of june units from interior military circles were put on alert and started their deployment towards the western borders.And so on.
Why then the catastrofic events that followed ?
2.Because the weapons do not fight by themselvs and the human factor in decisive.
-did not Know how to fight,or
-did not WANT to fight,or both.
I'll cite only one fact,in the first six weeks of war,Red Army lost 6,2 milion rifles and 70 % of mortars BUT only 28% of its cars and trucks (Krivosheev memoirs )A car can easily break,but a mortar,a steel tube ?
|Posted by: MMM September 06, 2010 02:45 pm|
| Yeah, that's what I also understood from the materials posted on his site. I hope he'll soon edit an English version. He makes way more sense than Suvorov/Rezun and doesn't seem that passionate; maybe because he's a historian!
Also, if one looks carefully on the site, one finds some .doc files for downloading!
LE: thanks, guina! Great book!
|Posted by: guina September 06, 2010 03:37 pm|
| You wellcome,
I want to draw your attention to another new wave russian historian,which,among others wrote a book called "Antisuvorov " and you'll love it.
Actually he is a very good historian,specialized in Jukov and Jukovs battles and some of his books can be bought on Amazon.Oh,his name is Alexei Isaev and its worth mentioning one of his last books "The Zeelow hights".
|Posted by: MMM October 16, 2010 06:32 pm|
| I just received a mail from Mr. Solonin, in response to something I wrote him on the site. He says that - even if it sounds funny - he has no offers from Western editors for his books, leading him to the belief that Stalin's, Brejnev's, Jukov's versions are prefered!
I hope that maybe after the end of the world crisis (yeah, like that's gonna be in the near future for us in Romania ) things would change.
|Posted by: Dénes October 17, 2010 09:34 am|
Did he at least try to contact some of these "Western" Publishers? Did he submit a synopsis of his work, including samples? Or he is just waiting to be contacted...
I am pretty sure there is market for such English language books, and therefore there are publishers who are interested in printing them.
|Posted by: MMM October 17, 2010 11:04 am|
| Well, that's what I thought, too! Here's the message sent to me - so figure out for yourself...
Perhaps he did try, because he edited some of his books in Latvia, Poland or something like that - so why wouldn't he want to enter the "serious", Western market?!
PS: feel free to contact him on the site, as he answered to me in less than 48 hours - from Friday at noon until Saturday evening!
|Posted by: guina October 17, 2010 12:50 pm|
|The info.i gave is not from him but from one of my friends in RF.I"ll check again ,but mr.Solonin must know better.|
|Posted by: MMM October 17, 2010 04:08 pm|
|Unfortunately, my level of Russian is NOT enough to understand / comprehend the subtle nuances... so I will just wait! Eventually, they'll be translated in English or French.|